Which states are taking the most aggressive stance toward “driving under the influence” (DUI)?
To find out, 2Pass and WalletHub compared the drunk driving penalties in all 50 states and D.C. You can find a complete breakdown below.
Overall Rank (1=Strictest) | State | Total Score | Criminal Penalties Rank | Prevention Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Arizona | 84.09% | 1 | 2 |
2 | Georgia | 70.45% | 2 | 19 |
3 | Alaska | 65.00% | 3 | 15 |
4 | Kansas | 64.09% | 3 | 19 |
4 | Oklahoma | 64.09% | 5 | 11 |
6 | Nebraska | 61.82% | 6 | 16 |
7 | Connecticut | 60.91% | 7 | 8 |
8 | Utah | 60.45% | 11 | 2 |
9 | Delaware | 55.91% | 10 | 11 |
10 | West Virginia | 54.55% | 9 | 25 |
11 | Colorado | 54.09% | 14 | 6 |
12 | Virginia | 52.27% | 14 | 11 |
13 | Texas | 51.36% | 8 | 36 |
14 | Louisiana | 50.91% | 14 | 16 |
15 | Washington | 50.45% | 20 | 6 |
16 | Oregon | 49.55% | 18 | 19 |
17 | Florida | 48.64% | 24 | 5 |
18 | Nevada | 46.82% | 23 | 11 |
19 | Illinois | 46.36% | 31 | 4 |
19 | Tennessee | 46.36% | 14 | 34 |
21 | California | 45.45% | 19 | 31 |
22 | Arkansas | 43.64% | 48 | 1 |
22 | Massachusetts | 43.64% | 13 | 44 |
24 | Iowa | 42.73% | 11 | 46 |
25 | Kentucky | 42.27% | 27 | 19 |
26 | Hawaii | 41.82% | 35 | 9 |
27 | Minnesota | 40.45% | 27 | 28 |
27 | South Carolina | 40.45% | 21 | 36 |
29 | New Mexico | 39.55% | 35 | 19 |
29 | New York | 39.55% | 24 | 33 |
31 | New Hampshire | 38.64% | 35 | 24 |
32 | Alabama | 38.18% | 35 | 25 |
33 | Rhode Island | 37.27% | 24 | 38 |
34 | Missouri | 36.82% | 40 | 28 |
35 | Maine | 36.36% | 48 | 16 |
35 | North Carolina | 36.36% | 27 | 38 |
37 | Indiana | 35.45% | 31 | 35 |
37 | Wisconsin | 35.45% | 46 | 25 |
37 | Wyoming | 35.45% | 40 | 32 |
40 | Montana | 35.00% | 21 | 47 |
41 | Mississippi | 34.09% | 48 | 28 |
42 | Vermont | 33.64% | 31 | 41 |
43 | Michigan | 30.91% | 40 | 43 |
43 | Pennsylvania | 30.91% | 46 | 38 |
45 | New Jersey | 30.45% | 45 | 42 |
46 | Maryland | 30.00% | 51 | 9 |
47 | Idaho | 29.55% | 27 | 49 |
47 | North Dakota | 29.55% | 40 | 45 |
49 | Ohio | 28.64% | 35 | 47 |
50 | District of Columbia | 22.27% | 31 | 50 |
51 | South Dakota | 20.45% | 40 | 50 |
Detailed Findings
Overall Rank | State | Min. Jail Time (1st conviction) | Min. Jail Time (2nd conviction) | DUI Is Automatic Felony | How Long Old DUI Factors Into Penalties | Administrative License Suspension | Vehicle Impound | Ignition Interlock Mandatory | Ignition Interlock Mandatory Period | Additional Penalties for High BAC | Mandatory Alcohol Assessment | Min. Fine (1st conviction) | Min. Fine (2nd conviction) | “No-Refusal” Sobriety Testing | Average Insurance Rate Increase After DUI | Child Endangerment Protection | Sobriety Checkpoints | Other Penalties | Total Score (See Methodology) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Arizona*** | 10 days | 90 days | Third Offense | 7 Years | 90 days | Yes | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 12 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $750 | $1750 | Yes | 37% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 84.09% |
2 | Georgia** | 10 days | 90 days | Fourth Offense | 10 years | 360 days | No | 2nd conviction | 12 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $300 | $600 | Yes | 47% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 70.45% |
3 | Alaska | 3 days | 20 days | Third Offense | 15 years | 90 days | Yes | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 6 months | above 0.15 BAC | No | $1500 | $3000 | Yes | 80% | Yes | No | No | 65.00% |
4 | Kansas* *** | 2 Days | 90 days | Third Offense | 10 years | 30 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 6 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $750 | $1250 | Yes | 46% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 64.09% |
4 | Oklahoma*** | 10 days | 5 days | Second Offense | 10 years | 180 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 18 months | above 0.15 BAC | No | $0 | $0 | Yes | 28% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 64.09% |
6 | Nebraska | 7 days | 30 days | Fourth Offense | 15 years | 90 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 6 months | above 0.15 BAC | No | $500 | $500 | Yes | 58% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 61.82% |
7 | Connecticut* | 2 days | 120 days | Third Offense | 10 years | 90 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 12 months | above 0.16 BAC | Yes | $500 | $1000 | No | 100% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 60.91% |
8 | Utah*** | 2 days | 10 days | Third Offense | 10 years | 120 days | Yes | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 18 months | above 0.16 BAC | Yes | $1370 | $1560 | Yes | 39% | Yes | Yes | No | 60.45% |
9 | Delaware*** | No minimum sentence | 60 days | Third Offense | 10 years | 90 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 14 months | above 0.16 BAC | Yes | $500 | $750 | Yes | 31% | Yes | Yes | No | 55.91% |
10 | West Virginia | No minimum sentence | 180 days | Third Offense | 10 years | 180 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .15 | 4.17 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $100 | $1000 | Yes | 59% | Yes | Yes | No | 54.55% |
11 | Colorado*** | 5 days | 10 days | Fourth Offense | 7 Years | 90 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 8 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $600 | $600 | Yes | 34% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 54.09% |
12 | Virginia | No minimum sentence | 30 days | Third Offense | 10 years | 7 days | Yes | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 6 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $250 | $500 | Yes | 42% | Yes | Yes | No | 52.27% |
13 | Texas* | 3 days | 30 days | Third Offense | For Life | 90 days | Yes | 2nd conviction | 12 months | above 0.15 BAC | No | $0 | $0 | Yes | 44% | Yes | No | No | 51.36% |
14 | Louisiana* *** | 2 days | 30 days | Fourth Offense | 10 years | 45 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 12 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $300 | $750 | Yes | 62% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 50.91% |
15 | Washington* | 1 day | 30 days | Fifth Offense | 7 years | 90 days | Yes | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 12 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $940.5 | $1195 | Yes | 28% | Yes | No | No | 50.45% |
16 | Oregon* *** | 2 days | 8 days | Fourth Offense | 10 years | 90 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 12 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $1000 | $1500 | No | 26% | Yes | No | Yes | 49.55% |
17 | Florida* | No minimum sentence | 10 days | Third Offense | 10 years | 180 days | Yes | 1st conviction / BAC .15 | 6 months | above 0.2 BAC | Yes | $500 | $1000 | Yes | 40% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 48.64% |
18 | Nevada*** | 2 days | 10 days | Third Offense | 7 years | 90 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 3 months | above 0.18 BAC | Yes | $400 | $750 | Yes | 29% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 46.82% |
19 | Illinois | No minimum sentence | 5 days | Third Offense | 10 years | 180 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 12 months | above 0.16 BAC | Yes | $0 | $0 | Yes | 70% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 46.36% |
19 | Tennessee | 2 days | 45 days | Fourth Offense | 10 years | None | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 12 months | above 0.2 BAC | Yes | $350 | $600 | Yes | 19% | Yes | Yes | No | 46.36% |
21 | California | 4 days | 10 days | Fourth Offense | 10 years | 120 days | Yes | No | 3 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $390 | $390 | Yes | 103% | Yes | Yes | No | 45.45% |
22 | Arkansas*** | 1 day | 7 days | Fourth Offense | 5 years | 180 days | Yes | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 12 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $150 | $400 | No | 68% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 43.64% |
22 | Massachusetts | No minimum sentence | 30 days | Third Offense | For Life | 90 days | No | 2nd conviction | 24 months | above 0.2 BAC | No | $500 | $600 | No | 67% | Yes | Yes | No | 43.64% |
24 | Iowa** | 2 Days | 7 days | Third Offense | 12 years | 180 days | No | No | 12 months | above 0.15 BAC | No | $625 | $1875 | No | 60% | Yes | No | Yes | 42.73% |
25 | Kentucky** | 2 days | 7 days | Fourth Offense | 10 years | 120 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .15 | 6 months | above 0.18 BAC | Yes | $200 | $350 | No | 48% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 42.27% |
26 | Hawaii | 2 days | 5 days | Fourth Offense | 5 years | 90 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 12 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $150 | $500 | No | 62% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 41.82% |
27 | Minnesota*** | No minimum sentence | 2 days | Second Offense | 10 years | 90 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .15 | 12 months | above 0.16 BAC | Yes | $0 | $0 | Yes | 37% | Yes | No | Yes | 40.45% |
27 | South Carolina*** | 2 days | 5 days | Fourth Offense | 10 Years | 30 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .15 | 6 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $400 | $2100 | No | 27% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 40.45% |
29 | New Mexico | No minimum sentence | 4 days | Fourth Offense | For Life | 180 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 12 months | above 0.16 BAC | No | $0 | $500 | No | 46% | No | Yes | Yes | 39.55% |
29 | New York | No minimum sentence | 5 days | Second Offense | 10 years | 30 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 6 months | above 0.18 BAC | Yes | $500 | $1000 | No | 49% | Yes | Yes | No | 39.55% |
31 | New Hampshire*** | No minimum sentence | 17 days | Fourth Offense | 10 years | 180 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .15 | 12 months | above 0.16 BAC | Yes | $500 | $750 | No | 79% | Yes | Yes | No | 38.64% |
32 | Alabama*** | No minimum sentence | 48 hours | Fourth Offense | 5 years | 90 days | No | 2nd conviction | 6 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $600 | $1100 | Yes | 54% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 38.18% |
33 | Rhode Island | No minimum sentence | 10 days | Third Offense | 5 years | None | Yes | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 24 months | above 0.1 BAC | No | $100 | $400 | No | 25% | Yes | No | Yes | 37.27% |
34 | Missouri | No minimum sentence | No minimum sentence | Third Offense | 5 years | 90 days | No | 2nd conviction | 6 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $0 | $0 | Yes | 39% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 36.82% |
35 | Maine | No minimum sentence | 7 days | None Offense | 10 years | 90 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 5 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $500 | $700 | Yes | 56% | Yes | Yes | No | 36.36% |
35 | North Carolina*** | 1 day | 7 days | Fourth Offense | 7 years | 30 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .15 | 12 months | above 0.15 BAC | No | $200 | $2000 | Yes | 112% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 36.36% |
37 | Indiana | No minimum sentence | 5 days | Second Offense | 5 years | 180 days | No | No | 12 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $0 | $0 | Yes | 56% | Yes | Yes | No | 35.45% |
37 | Wisconsin*** | No minimum sentence | 5 days | Fourth Offense | 10 years | 180 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .15 | 12 months | above 0.17 BAC | Yes | $150 | $350 | Yes | 51% | Yes | No | No | 35.45% |
37 | Wyoming | No minimum sentence | 7 days | Fourth Offense | 10 years | 90 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .15 | 6 months | above 0.15 BAC | Yes | $0 | $200 | No | 52% | Yes | No | Yes | 35.45% |
40 | Montana | 1 day | 7 days | Fourth Offense | For Life | None | No | 2nd conviction | 6 months | above 0.16 BAC | Yes | $600 | $1200 | No | 39% | Yes | No | Yes | 35.00% |
41 | Mississippi | No minimum sentence | 5 days | Third Offense | 5 years | 90 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 3 months | above 0 BAC | No | $250 | $600 | Yes | 27% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 34.09% |
42 | Vermont*** | No minimum sentence | 2.5 days | Third Offense | For Life | 90 days | Yes | 2nd conviction | 0 months | above 0 BAC | Yes | $0 | $0 | No | 67% | No | Yes | No | 33.64% |
43 | Michigan | No minimum sentence | 5 days | Third Offense | 7 years | None | No | 1st conviction / BAC .15 | 12 months | above 0.17 BAC | Yes | $100 | $200 | Yes | 9% | Yes | No | Yes | 30.91% |
43 | Pennsylvania* | No minimum sentence | 5 days | None Offense | 10 Years | None | No | 1st conviction / BAC .10 | 12 months | above 0.1 BAC | Yes | $300 | $300 | Yes | 25% | Yes | Yes | No | 30.91% |
45 | New Jersey | No minimum sentence | 2 days | None Offense | 10 years | None | No | 1st conviction / BAC .15 | 6 months | above 0.1 BAC | Yes | $250 | $500 | No | 47% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 30.45% |
46 | Maryland | No minimum sentence | 5 days | None Offense | 5 years | 90 days | No | 1st conviction / BAC .08 | 12 months | above 0 BAC | Yes | $0 | $0 | Yes | 51% | Yes | Yes | No | 30.00% |
47 | Idaho | No minimum sentence | 10 days | Third Offense | 10 years | 90 days | No | No | 12 months | above 0.2 BAC | No | $0 | $0 | Yes | 43% | Yes | No | No | 29.55% |
47 | North Dakota | No minimum sentence | 10 days | Fourth Offense | 7 years | 91 days | No | No | 1.1 months | above 0.18 BAC | Yes | $500 | $1500 | Yes | 33% | Yes | Yes | Yes | 29.55% |
49 | Ohio*** | 3 days | 10 days | Fourth Offense | 6 years | 90 days | No | 2nd conviction | 1.1 months | above 0.17 BAC | No | $375 | $525 | Yes | 31% | Yes | Yes | No | 28.64% |
50 | District of Columbia | No minimum sentence | No minimum sentence | None Offense | 15 years | 90 days | No | No | 0 months | above 0.2 BAC | No | $0 | $2500 | No | 30% | Yes | Yes | No | 22.27% |
51 | South Dakota | No minimum sentence | No minimum sentence | Third Offense | 10 years | 30 days | No | No | 0 months | above 0.17 BAC | No | $0 | $0 | Yes | 27% | No | Yes | Yes | 20.45% |
Source: https://wallethub.com/edu/dui-penalties-by-state/13549/
Methodology
WalletHub examined 15 key metrics to identify the strictest and most lenient states for DUI offenses.
The metrics we used and our weighting of them are detailed below. Please note that in considering minimum penalties for DUI conviction, we did not take into account a judge’s potential ability to reduce or suspend the sentence at his or her own discretion, as doing so would reflect unreliable subjectivity, especially given the lack of data on the frequency with which judges exercise this option.
Criminal Penalties:
-
- A) Minimum jail time (for 1st conviction, minimum sentence only)
- 10 days and over (10 points)
- 8 – 9 days (8 points)
- 6 -7 days (6 points)
- 4 – 5 days (4 points)
- 2 – 3 days (2 points)
- 0 – 1 day (0 points)
B) Minimum jail time (for 2nd conviction, minimum sentence only)
- 60 days and over (7 points)
- 50 – 59 days (6 points)
- 40 – 49 days (5 points)
- 30 – 39 days (4 points)
- 20 – 29 days (3 points)
- 10 – 19 days (1 point)
- Under 10 days (0 points)
- A) Minimum jail time (for 1st conviction, minimum sentence only)
-
- When is DUI automatically considered a felony?
- 2nd offense (5 points)
- 3rd offense (4 points)
- 4th offense (2 points)
- 5th offense (1 point)
- Never (0 points)
- When is DUI automatically considered a felony?
-
- How long does a previous DUI factor into penalties for a new DUI?
- More than 12 years (4 points)
- 12 years (3 points)
- 10 years (2 points)
- 7 years (1 point)
- Under 7 years (0 points)
- How long does a previous DUI factor into penalties for a new DUI?
-
- Are there additional penalties for high BAC?
- Over 0.10 (3 points)
- Over 0.15 (2 points)
- Over 0.16 or higher (1 point)
- No (0 points)
- Are there additional penalties for high BAC?
-
- A) Minimum fine (for 1st conviction, minimum sentence only)
- $1000 and over (3 points)
- $600 – $999 (2 points)
- $200 – $599 (1 point)
- Under $200 (0 points)
B) Minimum fine (for 2nd conviction, minimum sentence only)
- $2000 and over (2 points)
- $1200 – $1999 (1 point)
- $400 – $1199 (0.5 points)
- Under $400 (0 points)
- A) Minimum fine (for 1st conviction, minimum sentence only)
- Protection against child endangerment
- Yes (1 point)
- No (0 points)
Prevention:
-
- When is an ignition interlock mandatory?
- 1st conviction with 0.08 BAC (5 points)
- 1st conviction with 0.10 BAC (4 points)
- 1st conviction with 0.15 BAC (3 points)
- 2nd conviction (2 points)
- Not mandatory (0 points)
- When is an ignition interlock mandatory?
-
- Is there an “administrative” license suspension after arrest (and before conviction)?
- 120 days or more (4 points)
- 90-120 days (3 points)
- Less than 90 days (1 point)
- No (0 points)
- Is there an “administrative” license suspension after arrest (and before conviction)?
-
- How long is ignition interlock mandatory?
- 6 months or more (3 points)
- 3-6 months (2 points)
- Ignition interlock period determined by court (1 point)
- How long is ignition interlock mandatory?
-
- Is alcohol abuse assessment and/or treatment mandatory?
- Yes (2 points)
- No (0 points)
- Is alcohol abuse assessment and/or treatment mandatory?
-
- Vehicle Impound After Arrest
- Yes (2 points)
- No (0 points)
- Vehicle Impound After Arrest
-
- Average insurance rate increase after DUI.
- 100% or more increased cost (1 point)
- Above 75% increase in cost (0.75 points)
- Above 50% increase in cost (0.50 points)
- Above 25% increase in cost (0.25 points)
- Under 25% increase in cost (0 points)
- Average insurance rate increase after DUI.
-
- “No-refusal” initiative for rapid search warrants for sobriety testing
- Yes (1 point)
- No (0 points)
- “No-refusal” initiative for rapid search warrants for sobriety testing
-
- Sobriety checkpoints
- Yes (1 point)
- No (0 points)
- Sobriety checkpoints
- Other penalties
- If a state has any other penalties (1 point)
- No other penalties (0 points)
Total: 55 points
The final rankings were determined based on the total number of points each state accumulated. The highest score, correlating to the strictest state, was ranked first. Point totals were ultimately converted to percentages for comparison purposes.